LR(1)解析器中的左递归

Question

一个LR（1）分析器能否解析这种类型的语法？

S -> SA  | A
A -> aSb | ab

我正在尝试编写一个Java程序来实现这种类型的解析器，但是只有在没有左递归的语法中才能得到正确的结果。

- SegFault

Answer 1

LR(1)分析器可以处理一些类型的左递归语法，但并非所有左递归语法都是LR(1)。

让我们看看你特定的语法是否为LR(1)。扩展语法如下：

S' → S

S → SA | A

A → aSb | ab

因此，我们的构造集如下：

 (1)
 S' -> .S    [$]     (Go to 2)
 S  -> .SA   [$a]    (Go to 2)
 S  -> .A    [$a]    (Go to 3)
 A  -> .aSb  [$a]    (Shift on a and go to 4)
 A  -> .ab   [$a]    (Shift on a and go to 4)

 (2)
 S' -> S.    [$]     (Accept on $)
 S  -> S.A   [$a]    (Go to 3)
 A  -> .aSb  [$a]    (Shift on a and go to 4)
 A  -> .ab   [$a]    (Shift on a and go to 4)

 (3)
 S  -> A.    [$a]    (reduce on $ or a)

 (4)
 A  -> a.Sb  [$a]    (Go to 6)
 A  -> a.b   [$a]    (Shift on b and go to 10)
 S  -> .SA   [ab]    (Go to 11)
 S  -> .A    [ab]    (Go to 12)
 A  -> .aSb  [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)
 A  -> .ab   [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)

 (5)
 A  -> ab.   [$a]    (Reduce on a or $)

 (6)
 A  -> aS.b  [$a]    (Shift on b and go to 7)
 S  -> S.A   [ab]    (Go to 13)
 A  -> .aSb  [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)
 A  -> .ab   [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)

 (7)
 A  -> aSb.  [$a]    (Reduce on a or $)

 (8)
 A  -> a.Sb  [ab]    (Go to 14)
 A  -> a.b   [ab]    (Shift on b and go to 16)
 S  -> .SA   [ab]    (Go to 11)
 S  -> .A    [ab]    (Go to 12)
 A  -> .aSb  [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)
 A  -> .ab   [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)

 (9)
 S  -> SA.   [$a]    (Reduce on a or $)

 (10)
 A  -> ab.   [$a]    (Reduce on a or b)

 (11)
 S  -> S.A   [ab]    (Go to 13)
 A  -> .aSb  [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)
 A  -> .ab   [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)

 (12)
 S  -> A.    [ab]    (Reduce on a or b)

 (13)
 S  -> SA.   [ab]    (Reduce on a or b)

 (14)
 A  -> aS.b  [ab]    (Shift on b and go to 15)
 S  -> S.A   [ab]    (Go to 13)
 A  -> .aSb  [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)
 A  -> .ab   [ab]    (Shift on a and go to 8)   

 (15)
 A  -> aSb.  [ab]    (Reduce on a or b)

 (16)
 A  -> ab.   [ab]    (Reduce on a or b)

在这个文法中没有移进/规约冲突或规约/规约冲突，所以它应该是LR（1）文法（除非我在某个地方出错了！）

希望这可以帮到你！

- templatetypedef

---

好的，谢谢。我认为我在第一个集合上遇到了一些问题。如果我有S->S+A|a，那么first1(S) = [+,a]吗？ - SegFault

不，那是不正确的。FIRST_1(S) 是所有可以在从 S 派生出的字符串前面的终端符号集合。你不能以 + 开头派生一个字符串，因此 FIRST 集合只会是 {a}。 - templatetypedef

Answer 2

原来它也是SLR语法，因此LR有些过头了。使用SLR只需要10个状态，而不是LR的16个状态。

(1)
 S' -> .S    S => (Go to 2)
 S  -> .SA   A => (Go to 3)
 S  -> .A    a => (Shift and go to 4)
 A  -> .aSb     
 A  -> .ab   

 (2)
 S' -> S.    $ => (Accept on $)
 S  -> S.A   A => (Go to 5)
 A  -> .aSb  a => (Shift and go to 6)
 A  -> .ab   

 (3)
 S  -> A.    [$b] => (reduce on $ or b)

 (4)
 A  -> a.Sb  S => (Go to 7)
 A  -> a.b   A => (Go to 9)
 S  -> .SA   a => (Shift and go to 6)
 S  -> .A    b => (Shift and go to 8)
 A  -> .aSb  
 A  -> .ab   

 (5)
 S  -> SA.   [$b] => (reduce on $ or b)

 (6)
 A  -> a.Sb  S => (Go to 7)
 A  -> a.b   A => (Go to 3)
 S  -> .SA   a => (Shift and go to 4)
 S  -> .A    b => (Shift and go to 8)
 A  -> .aSb  
 A  -> .ab   

 (7)
 A  -> aS.b  A => (Go to 5)
 S  -> S.A   a => (Shift and go to 6)
 A  -> .aSb  b => (Shift and go to 10)
 A  -> .ab   

 (8)
 A  -> ab.   [$b] => (reduce on $ or b)

 (9)
 S  -> A.    [$b] => (reduce on $ or b)

 (10)
 A  -> aSb.  [$b] => (reduce on $ or b)

- tgoneil